When you live in Australia and speak about New Caledonia, cruising quickly hits your mind. That’s how almost all Australians visit New Caledonia’s collection of islands. It represents two third of the tourists visiting the archipelago (source). I think it is a waste. If you’re thinking about it, please read and you may want to reconsider your choice.
Why do I believe you shouldn’t pick a big cruise to visit New Caledonia? Because you won’t really experience New Caledonia.
I’m not against cruising in general. I actually love being on a boat. But a small boat. With sails. Travelling on a big boat with hundreds of people does not attract me at all. It’s just not for me: too many people, not enough independence… But I understand it can seduce more and more people. It’s a good way to relax, have everything included and nothing to worry about, and most of all to stay at the same place while still visiting different places. A great combo… when you go from a city to another city. Because if you go to small islands, I think you’re missing out too many great things.
This is what I loved during my trip to New Caledonia that you will not experience if you go there with a big cruise:
The diversity of the landscapes
I was stunned by how much the landscape was changing every time we were hopping in the car. Unfortunately, when you only spend one day at a destination with your big cruise, that’s not something you will be able to see. I’m biased as I often prefer to spend time in one region and fully explore it than ticking a large number of “I’ve been there” boxes.
But when planning your trip, keep in mind New Caledonia has a relaxed pace: we found out that planning several activities on the same day was challenging. Their relationship with time is vague, which was a great cultural experience… but it can become stressful for visitors with a list of things to do.
The kindness of the locals
Our great exchanges with the locals were one of the highlights of the trip. But if you arrive on a cruise, you’ll be amongst hundreds of other tourists. That will leave tiny room for opportunity to share something special with locals.
Moreover, the big cruises – because they are all-inclusive – don’t have a good reputation for creating a lot of value for the local community. Money doesn’t go to local businesses, restaurants, and hotels. The positive impact on the local community is little.
Learning more about the Kanak culture
During our trip, we had opportunities to ask many questions to many different people with a different history in the archipelago. We also ate at local places and tried many new things.
Coming from the boat, you will for sure be offered coconuts on the beach and some local delicacies. Unfortunately, you’ll miss all the stories around it. You’ll see shows organised by the locals, such as dances for example. But that’s cliché and kind of an old story. Staying on the island will give you more opportunities for real experiences.
It’s true that New Caledonia is a French-speaking country, and this can present some challenges to organise a trip or to communicate with locals. Still, there are many resorts around the islands that are used to welcome international customers. Travel agencies can also help you identifying the best activities if you don’t speak French. Going to a country where you don’t speak the language is great, and New Caledonia is not the hardest place to experience this!
The magnificent lagoons
New Caledonia is the worlds’ largest lagoon, and it meets the expectations. The beaches are fantastic. I loved the calm and serenity. The marine life is fascinating. But that’s when there is no cruise boat around. It’s a different picture when hundreds of people suddenly join in the postcard. More individuals in the water mean less wildlife and less visibility.
What happens when you double the number of people in one place in one day? Nothing good. I know tourism is never good for the environment but as a small group, we can always try to reduce our impact. Bringing suddenly hundreds of tourists in natural places is a lot worse than usual tourism. New Caledonians have started to realise this and now reduce the access to some endangered places when a cruise boat has arrived.
Also, cruise ships now have to anchor further away from the coast to limit the damage to the corals. Sadly, the decision was made after some damages were already done, causing some fish to be contaminated by a toxin which can generate food-poisoning (ciguatera) to humans. It’s not a direct danger to tourists as you need to absorb a lot of the toxin over time to actually get sick, but it remains a real problem for the local environment.
Views from the plane
That’s a bonus: I found it stunning to discover the islands from the plane. The views on the lagoons are unbelievable. It’s only a short flight to go from one island to another, and there are great views all the way.
By all means, if you were thinking of going to New Caledonia on a cruise, don’t remove it from your list just yet.
New Caledonia is amazing and worth a visit. I’m not telling you at all not to go. On the contrary: please, do visit New Caledonia, you’ll have a blast. People who do a cruise there actually love it. But my advice would be to consider a more ethical approach. You may be able to board a smaller and more eco-friendly boat for example. Or you could catch a plane and book some local cruising adventures that will let you take your time to explore the destination… You’ll see so much more of New Caledonia this way.
Have you ever been on a big cruise? Or have you visited a place that dramatically changed when the big cruise boat arrived? I’d love to hear about your experience! Please leave a comment below!
Eloise lives in Brisbane (Australia), but you won’t find her often in the city. When she is not disconnected underwater or in a national park, she loves sharing her travel tips and inspiring her readers to take care of our beautiful planet. She considers every weekend as a two-day holiday break. Her approach: you don’t always need to go far to travel. Still, she also enjoys exploring the world and discovering new cultures. Eloise is originally from France and, before moving to Brisbane, she lived in Sydney, Istanbul and England.